My upper elementary students loved this lesson. Teaching catastrophic events has sparked their thinking and writing ideas more than anything else I have tried. I went into this school year with the determination to make writing FUN! Of course, we have to follow standards but essay after essay can get very monotonous for kids.
They want to know about real life, true events, fires, explosions, deaths. Without sounding too morbid, life is beautiful but also full of compelling sorrow. It is a great thing that we have tragedy to balance out the joy. It is interesting to learn about drama and the mistakes of human beings from the past. It is also imperative. This Historical catastrophe lesson for 5th graders was a success.